Skip To Main Content

Lilley Fellow Connor Myers '27 Examines Gerrymandering and Congressional Fairness

What makes a congressional map fair, and how can fairness be measured? That question drove Connor Myers ’27’s Lilley Fellowship research, which he presented during Upper School Chapel on Oct. 13. Using math and computer modeling, Connor explored how to identify gerrymandering and determine whether congressional maps are drawn fairly.

Connor’s interest in the topic began in Middle School, when he encountered the unusually shaped congressional district that included Episcopal Academy from 2011 to 2018. "Gerrymandering is the practice of drawing political maps to favor a certain party," he explained. "And while these odd shapes first amused me in Middle School, I soon learned that gerrymandering is a real, active threat to our democracy."


But Connor learned that identifying gerrymandering isn't as simple as looking at a district's shape. He studied several mathematical ways to measure fairness, including district compactness, the efficiency gap, and proportionality. Each had limitations, particularly when accounting for political geography, or where voters live within a state. To deepen his understanding, Connor also consulted researchers from the University of Chicago and Duke University, including Dr. Christopher Donnay, Dr. Gregory Herschlag, and Dr. Jerry Reiter.

"From my research, I concluded that the most robust method for analyzing a map is ensemble outlier analysis," he said.

Using a Python programming tool called GerryChain, Connor modified an algorithm to generate thousands of alternative congressional maps. His model accounted for factors such as population, district shape, and county boundaries, but did not use partisan voting data, allowing him to compare existing maps against neutral alternatives.

Connor then put that approach to the test in Pennsylvania, generating 50,000 congressional maps and comparing them with the state's 2011 redistricting plan, which the Pennsylvania Supreme Court struck down in 2018.

Across three statewide elections, Connor found that Pennsylvania's 2011 map produced results seen in fewer than 0.5 percent of his neutral maps, indicating an unusual advantage for Republicans. His findings supported the court's conclusion that the map was gerrymandered.

He then examined Massachusetts, where Democrats have held every congressional seat for decades despite Republicans routinely receiving 35 to 40 percent of the statewide vote. After generating 40,000 alternative maps, Connor found that Democrats won every district in every simulation using 2012 election data.

The results showed Connor why political geography matters. While Pennsylvania's map stood out among the neutral alternatives, his Massachusetts findings suggested that the state's election results could be explained by where voters lived, rather than how district lines were drawn. "While ensemble analysis does not define fairness, it shows what maps generated by neutral means might look like," he explained.

Beyond his quantitative research, Connor volunteered with Fair Districts PA, a nonpartisan organization advocating for an independent citizens' redistricting commission in Pennsylvania. Through conversations with voters at polling places and community events and work with the organization's Youth Outreach Team, he gained a different perspective on the issue. "I was reminded that politics is, at its core, about people," Connor said. "We mustn't forget that these maps and charts are ultimately just representations of people."

Looking ahead to the Nov. 3 midterm elections, Connor encouraged eligible students to register and vote, emphasizing that individuals have the power to influence the political system.

Upper School History Teacher Topher Row, Hon. served as Connor's faculty mentor.

Established in 2018 by Mr. and Mrs. William Lilley III ’55, the Lilley Fellowship Fund awards research fellowships to students who exemplify academic curiosity, intellectual rigor, and scholarly passion. The Fellowship program is overseen by Director of Libraries Lorie Harding and is modeled after Yale University's Scholars of the House program that ran from 1945-1995.